Skip to main content

Tesla walks back plan to sue Cybertruck flippers (but resales are still discouraged)

Tesla isn't the only automaker with this type of policy

Tesla Cybertruck render on the road
Tesla

Tesla is rolling back plans to sue people who flip their Cybertrucks just days after the automaker made headlines for a new clause in its Terms & Conditions, which said the company might pursue legal action against Cybertruck resellers when the long-awaited truck finally makes its debut.

The clause threatening legal action seems to have disappeared from the company’s “Motor Vehicle Order Agreement Terms & Conditions,” though resales are still discouraged. Although a lawsuit may be off the table, Tesla is still threatening to cancel pre-orders while keeping the “Order Fee, Order Deposit and Transportation Fee” if it believes the order has “has been made with a view toward resale of the Vehicle or that has otherwise been made in bad faith.”

The EV manufacturer initially added a clause to the sale contract allowing it to sue people who resold their Cybertrucks within a year for $50,000 or the apparent profits from the sale — whatever was greater. If a buyer had wanted to resell their truck, they would have to give Tesla the right to repurchase it for its original sale price minus $0.25 for every mile it had been driven.

Now that the clause has gone, flipping could be a major issue. It has been suggested that there are up to two million pre-orders in place for the Tesla Cybertruck, and it may take up to a decade to clear that backlog. That could also be a “best case” scenario, with Tesla hoping production may hit 250,000 vehicles per year by 2025. However, as with the truck’s release date, those figures could be optimistic.

The vehicle isn’t even out yet, and people with early pre-orders are already attempting to flip them. Some of the orders, which were placed shortly after the Cybertruck’s 2019 unveiling, have been listed for as much as $10,000 on eBay.

A gavel
Sergei Tokmakov, Esq. https://Terms.Law / Pixabay

Legal threats are nothing new

Anti-flipping clauses are nothing new in the automotive world, and if Tesla stuck to its guns, then it wouldn’t be anything novel. Manufacturers like Ford have anti-flipping clauses for several vehicles, including the Ford GT. Ford also suggested its dealers implement a similar clause when the F-150 Lightning was in high demand — in an effort to discourage scalping. These clauses often have a time limit of one year or so and are aggressively enforced when implemented.

One high-profile case saw the Detroit-based manufacturer sue professional wrestler John Cena after the WWE star resold his GT for a profit. The case was settled out of court, with the money Cena made on the sale going to charity and an apology being issued.

Ferrari is also famous for the clauses bundled with its sales, some of which are similar to the ones Tesla proposed. If you’re among the few people allowed to buy a Ferrari with a limited run, then Ferrari wants first dibs if you ever sell it. Failure to adhere to this clause could result in a lawsuit and will definitely see you land on the company’s infamous blacklist. Porsche, GM, Aston Martin, and Rolls Royce are among the other companies that implement anti-flipping clauses in the sales contracts of their most anticipated or in-demand vehicles.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Dave McQuilling
Dave has spent pretty much his entire career as a journalist; this has included jobs at newspapers, TV stations, on the…
Hyundai follows Tesla’s playbook by slashing the price of the Ioniq 6 to stay competitive
2024 Hyundai Ioniq 6 parked outside.

The Hyundai Ioniq 6 is often compared to the Tesla Model 3 as its strongest competitor. It’s a midsize sedan with a fastback body style similar to the Model 3. It’s also available with almost the same battery range as the Tesla Model 3. The similar characteristics of these electric cars are uncanny, and there is a high chance Hyundai knows that well.

However, Tesla slashed the prices of the Tesla Model 3 and Tesla Model Y last month to stay ahead of the competition. The Tesla Model 3 now starts at $38,990 — and if you qualify for the EV tax credit, it could be cheaper. Well, you have to admit, this could have been the swing factor for most people shopping for electric vehicles who were split between buying a Tesla Model 3 or a Hyundai Ioniq 6.

Read more
Tesla has ‘waning marketability’ but still makes 5X more per vehicle than GM, Ford: Report
How Tesla's EV competition stacks up
Tesla Model 3 and Model Y parked in front of a city skyline on a runway.

It's a script we've seen time and time again. When the first big name becomes known for something, we as a society embrace and obsess about it for a while, and then slowly, we lose interest around the same time new competitors enter the once-monopolized market. For example, Ray Kroc helped introduce the world to McDonald's, and we reveled in french fries and milkshakes until Burger King, Wendy's, and a few dozen others tried to either step up their game or begin playing. Slowly, the once unimaginable profit margins the Golden Arches saw had to get trimmed to allow Micky D to stay at the head of the pack. Though neither is the first to do what they did, like McDonald's, Tesla has become the face of its industry. And also similarly, Elon Musk's company is beginning to feel the slow shift in profit that real competition brings.

Tesla hasn't had much competition until now
Let's face it: until very recently, Tesla has had very little in the way of genuine competition in the EV sector. Over the last decade, even the big three American companies have barely been able to grab any appreciable portion of the EV pie other than in the truck realm. A big reason is that Tesla isn't a part of that market due to Elon's geometric Mad Max Cybertruck being delayed since 2022.

Read more
People are reselling their Tesla Cybertruck reservations for up to $10,000 on eBay
Tesla Cybertruck reservations are the new Taylor Swift tickets
Tesla Cybertruck render on the road

Pre-orders for the Cybertruck opened up back in 2019, and people who slapped down their $100 deposit have had a bit of a rough ride since then. The truck's divisive appearance, and a mishap at the unveiling that resulted in a couple of "bulletproof" windows being easily shattered, didn't temper Tesla supporters' enthusiasm. Some 200,000 people pre-ordered the wedge-shaped EV shortly after it was announced, and according to some reports, that number has increased tenfold since then. This may be an issue for people who haven't nabbed an early pre-order but want to own the long-awaited steel-clad pickup.

The long-awaited EV has been delayed multiple times, and when deliveries do eventually start, it’s going to be more of a trickle than a deluge. According to Musk himself, production will eventually hit 250,000 units per year. But Tesla’s plant won’t hit that capacity until 2025 at the earliest.

Read more