Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Travel

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Why you really shouldn’t book an Airbnb in NYC anymore

There are plenty of great NYC hotels you could choose instead

Ashley Jones
By
The NYC skyline at night
Michał Ludwiczak/Pexels / Pexels

The city that never sleeps is putting Airbnb to bed. New York City has recently put a damper on one of the trendiest ways to stay when you visit the Big Apple: Airbnb rentals. The new law sets rules in place that are so strict that Airbnb itself has coined it a “de facto ban” on business. 

The new law will most definitely lead to an uptick in hotel bookings over Airbnb and other short-term rentals in the city, and it’s causing quite a stir with travelers and hosts alike. While Airbnb, Vrbo, and others can still operate in New York, the rules are now so tight that it’s definitely not the same experience anymore, and hotels will likely be the go-to for travelers once again.

A hand opening a hotel room door with the room interior in the background
Pixabay/Pexels

NYC’s new Airbnb law: what it means for travelers

So, what exactly is this new law all about? New York City implemented the Short-Term Rental Registration Law, aka Local Law 18, at the beginning of 2022 but didn’t start cracking down on it until more recently — Sept. 5, 2023, to be exact. The law requires anyone who wants to rent out their place on platforms like Airbnb to register with the Mayor’s Office of Special Enforcement (OSE). 

Recommended Videos

Sounds easy enough, right? But wait, there’s more!

Related

The most significant caveats the new law evokes are that hosts must also be present during their guests’ stay, and they can’t rent out their entire apartment or home anymore. So, if you don’t want to stay in the same space as the person renting it out, a hotel is now your only option. 

Though the new law is all about cracking down on illegal short-term rentals, it puts travelers in an understandable bind — especially those who used Airbnb and other vacation rentals as a convenient way to ensure enough space for everyone in their group. 

New York City isn’t the only place cracking down on Airbnb. Cities like Los Angeles, San Francisco, and even international destinations like Amsterdam and Paris are imposing their own restrictions. The goal is to address concerns like noise, trash, and housing shortages that can result from short-term rentals. 

The top of the New Yorker hotel in NYC
Luis Quintero/Pexels

Hosts take a hit while guests hit up hotels

Now, when you attempt to search for a stay through Airbnb in NYC, you’ll notice a significant drop in available listings. In fact, of the available listings, finding what you want may be incredibly challenging, given the new restrictions. 

Even as an avid fan of booking a condo or home for my family vs. a hotel, I personally would not choose to stay in a three-bedroom apartment where the host stays in the main bedroom, and my family shares the remaining two. I have nothing against the hosts left on the platform, but I value my privacy over a bit of extra space while on vacation.

If you choose to continue using the platform for NYC stays, rest assured that you won’t face any legal consequences for booking a place that violates this law. Instead, hosts will face fines for violations ranging from $100 to a whopping $5,000, depending on the severity. It’s a tough blow for many New Yorkers who were using short-term rentals to make ends meet, especially in a city where the cost of living is notoriously high.

While Airbnb’s future in NYC might be uncertain, it’s clear that the platform isn’t going away anytime soon. But if you’re planning a trip to NYC and thinking about booking an Airbnb, be prepared for slim pickings and a very different experience. The days of living like a local in a trendy Manhattan apartment are over — unless you’re cool with an in-house host. While the law aims to address a host of issues and complaints, it’s undeniably making travel tougher for guests and giving hosts headaches. Whether this trend continues in other cities or if Airbnb finds a way to adapt remains to be seen, but for now, the Airbnb game in NYC has definitely changed. Thankfully, there are plenty of amazing NYC hotels to choose from instead.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Ashley Jones
Ashley Jones
Ashley is a freelance journalist with bylines across a range of online and print publications.
Why air travel feels so expensive: Airlines will make a record $118B in extra fees this year
Baggage, seat selection, and more — airlines are making us pay
Interior of an airport with people stanidng in the shadows in front of a window

Airlines worldwide are set to make an anticipated record high of nearly $118 billion in revenue from ancillary sales this year, according to a study from IdeaWorks and CarTrawler. Ancillary sales include baggage fees, seat selection, and other air travel surcharges that airlines add to the base price of your ticket — you’ve probably noticed them driving up the price of air travel recently.
The staggering earnings in 2023 represent a 7.7% surge from pre-pandemic records and highlight a profound shift in the airline industry’s revenue model. It also reflects a stark reality for travelers: the days of straightforward ticket prices are long gone. The study sheds light on this escalating trend, showcasing the various fees airlines impose on passengers and what’s driving the change.

Why do airlines charge so many extra fees?
In the quest for profitability amidst competitive — aka low — ticket pricing, airlines have turned to tacking on extra fees for travelers, transforming these once supplementary charges into a lucrative revenue stream. “Airfares, on an inflated adjusted basis, have been declining for more than a decade,” IdeaWorks president Jay Sorensen noted in the study. “Low fares and ancillary revenue are joined at the hip. You can’t have one without the other.”
But, as shown by the continued year-over-year revenue increase for add-on fees industry-wide, this is no longer a matter of only budget airlines asking passengers to foot the bill for bags, extra legroom, and other “amenities” in flight. Large airlines such as British Airways, Air France, and KLM have ventured into charging fees for premium business class seats, expanding the spectrum of ancillary charges across the pond.
American Airlines, Delta Airlines, and United Airlines have been at the forefront of the fee frenzy in recent years. Baggage fees have been a substantial source of revenue for these carriers, with American Airlines’ baggage fees, Delta’s baggage fees, and United Airlines’ baggage fees contributing significantly to their bottom lines. It’s not just luggage; American Airlines and United Airlines seat selections are also now subject to additional fees, further intensifying the expense of flying.

Read more
Airline news: Alaska Airlines plans to buy Hawaiian Airlines, but it’s not a done deal (yet)
If the deal closes, Alaska Airlines will pay $1.9B for the airlines
Alaska Airlines plane flying in sky

Alaska Airlines announced Sunday it will acquire Hawaiian Airlines for $1.9 billion. This leaves many customers wondering what this might mean for them, as well as the future of air travel. The merger will allow Alaska Airlines to triple flights from Hawaii to destinations across North America. It will also allow for long-haul flights to and from Asia. However, the merger is not finalized yet.
The details of the merger
The merger deal is expected to close at $1.9 billion and should create earnings of nearly $235 million over the next two years, according to Alaska Airlines. “We’ve always been a growth airline and, with this combination, we intend to grow more, both domestically and internationally,” Alaska’s chief executive, Ben Minicucci, said in an interview with the New York Times.

With the two airlines combined, service would be available to 138 destinations, including nonstop flights from the United States to locations in Central America, Mexico, Asia, and Australia. 
Possible hurdles to consider
The merging of the two airlines is likely to be criticized by President Joe Biden’s Justice Department, who recently won a lawsuit to break up a partnership between JetBlue Airways and American Airlines. The Justice Department has enforced antitrust laws to prevent mergers, acquisitions, and other deals that would reduce competition in the aviation industry.

Read more
TSA bans these popular holiday items, so don’t even try to bring them onto your next flight
TSA has a naughty list for holiday items
Security check sign in airport

Flying during the holidays comes with a unique interaction with TSA. The TSA rules become stricter as airports teem with festive travelers and all of their holiday-themed belongings. Before you bring your holiday goodies to the airport, however, it's important to be aware of what you can and cannot bring on the plane.

TSA liquid rules
Before diving into the specifics, it's important to be aware of the TSA liquid rules. The TSA liquids rule, often referred to as the 3-1-1 rule, applies to passengers bringing liquids in their carry-on luggage. 

Read more