Skip to main content

Buffalo Trace releases its oldest Eagle Rare bourbon yet

Meet Eagle Rare 25, a new (old) bourbon offering from Buffalo Trace

Eagle Rare 25
Buffalo Trace Buffalo Trace

If you’re a fan of whiskey (specifically bourbon), you’re likely well aware of the prowess of the Buffalo Trace Distillery. Makers of Pappy Van Winkle, Weller, and other iconic brands, you’d have a hard time finding a bad expression from this award-winning distillery. One of its most popular brands is Eagle Rare. Eagle Rare is aptly named because many of its expressions, including its 17-year-old expression, aren’t easy to find in the wild for retail prices. This bourbon is highly sought-after and sells for large amounts of money on the secondary market.

And while this whiskey is rare, get ready for a new obsession-worthy expression as Buffalo Trace just announced the launch of Eagle Rare 25, the oldest expression to be released from the Eagle Rare range. But since it took twenty years before it was ready, its release is the end of decades of patience from Buffalo Trace’s $20 million-plus experimental program.

The brand has spent years experimenting with barrel charring levels, temperature, airflow, light impact, and various other things that affect aging. Eagle Rare 25 is the first release from Warehouse P, one of the two experimental warehouses.

“Eagle Rare 25 defies the conventional limits of typical bourbon aging,” Buffalo Trace Master Distiller Harlen Wheatley said in a press release about the whiskey. “When crafting whiskey in conditions like those we experience in Kentucky, two reactions happen over time: more liquid is lost due to evaporation – also known as angel’s share – and extraction of flavors from the barrel becomes more intense, often leading older whiskeys to taste over-oaked, astringent, and dry. The unique set of aging conditions in Warehouse P has allowed us to create a 25-year-old bourbon that smooths out the extractions and highlights the desirable flavors found in ultra-aged American whiskey products.”

The distillers believe that not only is Eagle Rare 25 great because it was made with high-quality ingredients and matured for more than twenty years, but they also think that the experimental aging process makes for a one-of-a-kind aroma and flavor experience.

According to the distillery, the 101-proof whiskey carries a nose of charred oak, bitter chocolate, dried cherries, and vanilla cream and a palate of dried fruits, butterscotch, and toasted vanilla beans. The finish is lingering, warm, and ends with a ton of spices, including cracked black pepper. Sipping it is truly an intense, sublime experience.

Not only is the juice inside remarkable, but the bottle itself is spectacular. It features a custom-made sterling silver wing that’s hand-hammered around every hand-blown crystal decanter.

Even if you have a lot of extra cash lying around, you won’t have an easy time getting your hands on a bottle of Eagle Rare 25. That’s because only around 200 bottles will be released to select retailers and restaurants. The suggested retail price is a staggering $10,000 per 750ml bottle. But that’s nothing if you have limitless cash and a penchant for high-quality bourbon. If only this was the case for all of us (or even some of us).

Editors' Recommendations

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
The best red wine under $20: Our top picks
Interested in a red wine with more quality than its sub-$20 price tag would suggest? Read on
Red wine being poured into glass

Anybody who's been abroad knows you can drink great wine on the cheap. Can you do the same here in the U.S.? The answer is yes, if you know what to look for.

The American wine scene is as vibrant as ever, and with that comes a whole host of options, from bottom shelf to high-end collector's items. In the red wine category, there's an ocean of riches to enjoy, from food-friendly Chianti to winter-ready cabernet franc. They come from all over, from the countryside of Italy to California's Sonoma County and even Washington state.

Read more
10 amazing gifts for the wine enthusiast in your life
What do you get someone who loves wine? (Besides wine, of course)
Estelle champagne coups

Most of us have a wine lover on our Christmas list this year. And if not, maybe that person is you, in which case welcome to the club. Enjoy it, and read on for some fabulous ways to treat yourself this season. Either way, finding the best gifts for wine lovers that don't include tacky "it's wine o'clock" wall art or tired wine gift baskets can be a daunting task. That's why we've decided to save you the headache and compile a list of our very favorite wine gifts for your very favorite wine enthusiast.

Hoopes Vineyard bundle
Hoopes Vineyard is a Napa Valley treasure that just gets everything right. Their exquisite wine is only matched by the beauty of their gorgeous vineyard and the loving passion that is so obviously poured into their winemaking process. This bundle is for every wine-lover on your list and includes a bottle of 2018 Oakville Cabernet Sauvignon, a bottle of Oasis Shrubs (flavored apple cider vinegar for drinking or cooking), a Hoopes embroidered apron, a jar of Hoopes Vineyard tomato sauce, and a candle made from recycled wine bottles.

Read more
It’s time to pay attention to Hawaiian rum — why this liquor should be on your bar cart
Hawaii grows a lot more than just pineapples
A Kuleana Rum Works sugarcane field.

While craft beer and whiskey tend to get the headlines, there’s another homegrown beverage gaining a much-deserved following. It goes by Hawaiian rum, and if you haven’t started paying serious attention to the fine liquor, now’s the time.

Kuleana Rum Works is a great example, one of several shining stars emerging from the Hawaiian spirits scene. Granted, Hawaii has a bit of an advantage for rum, with its tropical climate ideal for growing sugarcane (Louisiana and a few other states are trying their hand, too), but you still have to make the stuff. And the results are as complex and exciting as anything coming out of the Caribbean. In fact, these sip-worthy rums deserve to be in the same conversation as single malt whiskies or coveted Scotches.

Read more